First attempt - these dresses were gorgeous, but a bit too much - but the candy apple dress color was so gorgeous!
We liked the strapless, but one of the ladies is a mom and would be bending down a lot all night to pick-up her girls and didn't want to be showing everything. The lady on the left ended up staying with the strapless (she looked amazing, it fit her body really well).
This dress fit amazing on my lady on the far left, although she ended up altering it by making two straps out of it and it looked really great (plus then she could wear a bra). This dress is hard to wear with a bra. The lady on the right with the pink dress had a hard time getting her size D girls into the dress - it is really fit for more like B or C size cups.
This was almost perfect - the lady on the left altered her straps, the lady with the black dress looked amazing and didn't change a thing, the lady on the right with the pink chose a different dress with a sweetheart neckline, and the lady on the right went for the illusion alter dress instead so she could bend down. My younger sister was also in the wedding (as you will see below, and she went for the regular halter top dress without alterations).The end result:
The girls dresses (left to right); Halter, Strapless, Illusion Halter, Sweetheart, Halter turned to Strap
I took me only one trip to one bridal store to find my dress (more on that next), but for the girls dresses we looked at a bunch of different websites and stores. My girls are from three different states (Ohio, Virginia, and Illinois), so we had to do our research before our only weekend shopping together. We bought our dresses at the end of March and mid-April, and the wedding was in September, which was really good timing. All the dresses were in by mid-July.
David's Bridal had the best prices, and with being a national company it was easy to find local David's Bridals for my girls to order near their home.
Originally I really wanted Horizon for my color, but it was way too bright (would've been great for a summer, outdoor wedding though). One of my girls was trying on a dress and the only color in her size was Serene and we didn't like the dress, but we loved the color so much that we changed it.
As a photographer of many weddings, there is nothing I hate more than when brides fit the dresses around one girl (usually the one with this amazing body), and the rest of the girls have to squeeze into the same dress style that looks horrible on them. I couldn't do that to my girls - so they got to choose whatever style they wanted. The only compromise was that they wear the same color, and we choose all short/tea-length/or long.
Now I must say my girls have amazing figures, but the above pictures give you an idea of what the dresses look like on girls with different cup sizes, waist sizes and hips. The biggest thing was actually not the waist size (David's Bridal is great about hiding tummies and hips and not being too clingy), but the bra size - a lot of the dresses were made for B and C cups.
Here is one of the groomsman in a Men's Warehouse midnight vest & tie, and my bridesmaid in a gorgeous David's Bridal Serene dress (it was originally haltered, and she had it altered to be two-strapped).
My husband really wanted a platinum vest, but with his fair skin, red hair, and myself in a champagne dress, after trying on a different vest from Men's Warehouse we loved the Latte vest and tie! It was perfect with a light skin tone and looked great against my champagne/ivory dress. 
For the Dads we did the classic black and it looked amazing!
